Don't you think "estar" is first used to indicate a location, before describing moods and states ? i was surfing on forums when i read your comments; as i learnt the use of "estar" as the way to designate something in the space, i would be really surprised to discover that.
but it's possible as i learnt spanish at school in France, and ce n'est pas une sinécure, ou plutot si ! pour les profs nullards qu'on a dû se carrer pendant nos études
hace veinte anos los profesores de lengua utilizaban métodos arcaicas y proscribian el uso de las listas de vocabulario ; era una epoca muy ideologica con muchos tontos Afortunadamente, despues fue Memrise !
Actually it should be, "donde es la biblioteca?" since it's there to stay. Esta is used for moods or states that are temporary ;0)
Posted by sfrenchie 3/23/12 (1 year ago)I was specifically referring to a mobile library.....
Posted by Mangotastic 3/23/12 (1 year ago)Don't you think "estar" is first used to indicate a location, before describing moods and states ? i was surfing on forums when i read your comments; as i learnt the use of "estar" as the way to designate something in the space, i would be really surprised to discover that.
Posted by pinto 3/23/12 (1 year ago)but it's possible as i learnt spanish at school in France, and ce n'est pas une sinécure, ou plutot si ! pour les profs nullards qu'on a dû se carrer pendant nos études
Posted by pinto 3/23/12 (1 year ago)Motion to withdraw :0) Searching Internet I found: Estar is used for location of things and people (but not events) So Mango was right.
Posted by sfrenchie 3/23/12 (1 year ago)ok, so my french teachers weren't so bad even if they were boring ;-)
Posted by pinto 3/23/12 (1 year ago)Jeje...profesores aburridos huh!
Posted by sfrenchie 3/23/12 (1 year ago)hace veinte anos los profesores de lengua utilizaban métodos arcaicas y proscribian el uso de las listas de vocabulario ; era una epoca muy ideologica con muchos tontos Afortunadamente, despues fue Memrise !
Posted by pinto 3/23/12 (1 year ago)LOL, well said.
Posted by sfrenchie 3/23/12 (1 year ago)http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UXno3lhVGOM
Posted by Mangotastic 3/24/12 (1 year ago)he descubierto a troy y abed ; me gusta muchisimo su estilo. No existe todavia la version francesa de su show
Posted by pinto 3/24/12 (1 year ago)